More 4 Less #1: Lighting

Who doesn't {LOVE} to find something at a less expensive price?  
I'm starting a new series at SAS Interiors, called More 4 Less, where I will compare high-ticket items with lower priced deals.  Is it worth saving some money?...YOU decide!

  

Pottery Barn: $299

 

 Lighting Universe, Lighting Enterprises F-1495/9485 Transitional Floor Lamp, ORB: $235

                                                

Butterscotch Parallels Giclee Boom Flr Lamp      Vanilla Stripe Giclee Shade Flr Lamp

     Shop Floor Lamps: $199

 

        

Amazon Kenroy Home 20953ORB Sweep Floor Lamp, Oil Rubbed Bronze: $153

           

JCPenney Adjustable Metal Column Floor Lamp by studio: $114.99

Which light is your favorite?  Is the PB light worth the $300 price tag?  

I'm kind of diggin' the JCP fixture for $15;)  (just wish it was in oil rubbed bronze)